Here goes: I added the depth chart year I pulled them from.
QB - QB Mohammed Foster 6-0 194 Jr Taft School (Watertown, CT) 5.0 of 5.0 [Scrambling] (2020) - MoFo is clearly the greatest quarterback in school history. He has the school's only Heisman trophy and if we're being realistic his 2020 season was the greatest in site history. No bias whatsoever.
RB - RB Fred Preston 5-9 191 Sr George Washington (Charleston WV) 4.5 of 4.5 [Power] (2014) - It was a close call between Fred and Mohamed Mustafa, but Fred had roughly 1,300 yards on 5.49 YPC in 2014. Mustafa was a 4 year starter, but never came close to that level of production.
FB - FB Eli Keener 5-10 229 (Sr) Pendleton County (Franklin, WV) 4.0 of 4.0 [Pass Blocking] (2023) - Best FB in school history
WR - WR J.C. Weldon 6-2 183 Jr Saint Albans (St. Albans, WV) 5.0 of 5.0 [Target] (2020)
WR Todd Sykes 6-1 182 (Sr) East Hardy (BakerWV) 4.0 of 4.0 [Target] (2017)
WR Corey Easley 5-9 192 (So) University (Morgantown WV) 3.5 of 4.5 [Speed] (2023)
WR Elias Langston 6-0 227 Jr Wayne Hills (Wayne, NJ) 4.0 of 4.0 [Target] (2021)
Pretty solid wide receiving corp here. Weldon won the Biletnikoff in 2020 and had nearly 1,800 yards. Todd Sykes is the school record holder in receiving yards and touchdowns. Easley has only played 1 year, but he amassed over 1,000 yards and would be the perfect slot man on this team. Langston was the 2018 conference freshman of the year and was a consistent college player.
TE - TE Jason Dupree 6-2 207 Sr North Platte Community College (North Platte, NE) 4.5 of 4.5 [Receiving] (2020) - Easily the best TE in school history. Had double digit touchdowns and over 900 yards in 2020.
LT - OT Owen Stover 6-3 273 Sr Hiwassee College (Madisonville, TN) 4.0 of 4.0 [Pass Blocking] (2019) - Our current guy Hanson is a 4/4.5, but he's only played 1 game for us so I'm going to go with Owen here. Stover anchored a pretty solid line in 2019.
LG - OG Prince Calloway 6-5 333 (Sr) Housatonic Valley Regional (CT) 4.5 of 4.5 [Pass Blocking] (2020) - Calloway played RG on the 2020 team, but will slide to LG here.
C - C Tim Keaton 6-7 286 (Sr) Valley (Smithers, WV) 4.5 of 4.5 [Run Blocking] (2017) - Only pro-potential center the team has ever had.
RG - OG Mario Lawton 6-3 273 (Sr) Roane State Community College (Harriman TN) 5.0 of 5.0 [Run Blocking] (2023) - Potential first round pick in the upcoming draft
RT - OT Kevin Hill 6-7 313 (Sr) Oak Hill (Oak HillWV) 4.5 of 4.5 [Run Blocking] (2017) - Could eventually be the current guy Julian Vincent, but this guy was a major cog in the team that won 11 games in 2011.
LE - DE John Jones 6-8 268 (Jr) Lincoln West (ClevelandOH) 4.0 of 4.0 [Run Stop] (2018) All conference selection in 2017 and 2018 - he finished his career with 87 tackles and 19 sacks,
DT - DT Hudson Adam 6-0 310 (Sr) Mount Carmel Area (Mount Carmel PA) 5.0 of 5.0 [2-Gap] (2020)
DT Riley Reardon 6-0 315 Sr Nicholas County (Summersville WV) 4.0 of 4.0 [1-Gap]
Hudson was an all american in 2020 and the 2019 conference defensive player of the year. Rley Reardon doesn't put up great sack numbers, but he has a knack for getting TFLs and gets credit for being one of the better players on a solid defense.
RE - DE Aaron Pagan 6-6 271 Sr CCBC-Dundalk (Dundalk, MD) 4.0 of 4.0 [Blitz] (2022) - Pagan was an all conference performer in 2021 and had a pretty solid 12 sack season. In the future this would likely go to my current DE Acuna, but he's only played 1 game.
LOLB - OLB Andre Gasaway 6-0 220 (Sr) H.D. Woodson (Washington, DC) 5.0 of 5.0 [Pass Man-to-Man] (2016) - Gassaway is the best OLB in school history.
MLB - ILB Dick McCready 6-2 218 (Sr) Williamstown (WilliamstownWV) 5.0 of 5.0 [Pass Zone] (2017) - All Conference selection in 2017 - Dick has put together a decent pro career.
ROLB - OLB Ahmed London 6-2 239 Sr Williamson (Williamson WV) 4.5 of 4.5 [Coverage] (2019) Very solid OLB in college. Had a huge play to get us to 6-5 and bowl eligbile against Maryland
CB - CB Jack Weisensee 6-0 167 Sr Charles D. Owen (Black Mountain NC) 4.0 of 4.0 [Man Coverage] (2019)
CB Lamont Carson 5-11 198 (Jr) Douglas Freeman (Richmond, VA) 4.0 of 4.0 [Man Coverage] (2022)
CB Harry Conner 5-11 185 (Jr) Saint Albans (St. Albans WV) 4.0 of 4.0 [Man Coverage] (2023)
We've never had elite corners here at WVU. Jack probably was the most consistent of the bunch, but Lamont had a pretty spectacular freshman year during our playoff run.
SS - SS Rob Evans 6-3 182 (Sr) Webster County (Upper GladeWV) 5.0 of 5.0 [Man Coverage] (2017) - All conference performer in 2016 and 2017 - Rob Evans is a hard hitting local guy.
FS - FS Preston Evans 6-0 190 (So) Joaquin (Joaquin TX) 3.5 of 3.5 [Man Coverage] (2023) - We have had better rated free safeties in program history including 4.5/4.5 Mekhi Cringle, but none have made the impact that Evans seems to have made. A close runner up in this was 2019 3.5 safety Julian Reid who made the all conference team.
K - K Brent Hankton 6-4 215 Sr Matewan (Matewan WV) 5.0 of 5.0 [Power] (2014) - Hank the tank narrowly defeats Felipe Munoz. Munoz struggled a bit his senior year or it would have been him.
P -P Brian Brown 5-9 163 (So) Williamstown (Williamstown WV) 4.0 of 4.0 [Power] (2014) - greatest player in cfbhc history.. oh wait... this isn't the right Brian Brown?... oh well then P A.J. Kinney 5-9 205 Sr Princeton (Princeton, WV) 4.5 of 4.5 [Accuracy] (2016) - Kinney had a pretty solid career and made the all-conference team in 2016.
KR/PR - RB Jamel Herron 5-9 203 (Sr) Swain County (City, NC) 3.0 of 3.0 [Speed] (2023) - Jamel is weirdly good at returning. All-conference in 2020 and is currently the Big XII's all time leader in both categories (i think).
Overall this is a really fun group. It might not have as much top end talent as some other schools' all time teams, but I think we would pull several upsets in a hypothetical tournament.